Head-to-head · Value Score
Eden vs NewSelf
Two GLP-1 deals, scored on the same six factors. Eden lands a Value Score of 91, NewSelf a 87. Here's what each one really costs past month one — and where each one bites back.
Eden
Grade A · Excellent
Advertised price
$99/mo
Save ~72% vs brand self-pay
NewSelf
Grade A- · Great Deal
Advertised price
$134.99/mo at every dose
$134.99/mo at every dose (as low as $99.97 on a longer plan)
Save ~61% vs brand self-payThe verdict
Eden takes it on Value Score, 91 to 87 — an est. $99/mo first month, with no teaser step-up baked in. NewSelf isn't out of it: Someone who expects to titrate high and wants the price to stay where it started.
Deal-by-deal
The numbers that decide it. Green ✓ marks the stronger side on each line.
| Deal | Eden | NewSelf |
|---|---|---|
| Value Score | 91 (A) | 87 (A-) |
| Advertised price | $99/mo | $134.99/mo at every dose (as low as $99.97 on a longer plan) |
| Save vs brand self-pay | ~72% | ~61% |
| Semaglutide | $99/mo | $134.99/mo at every dose (as low as $99.97 on a longer plan) |
| Tirzepatide | $129/mo | $224.99/mo at every dose (as low as $144.49 on a longer plan) |
| Both molecules | Yes | Yes |
| Pricing | Flat — no step-up | Flat — no step-up |
| Coverage | All 50 states | 49 states |
Factor by factor
The six factors behind each Value Score. The orange bar marks the stronger side. See the methodology.
Eden
Eden sells compounded semaglutide for $99 a month and tirzepatide for $129, all-inclusive and the same at every dose, filled by its own pharmacy or vetted partners.
Why it's a deal
- Names its medical team rather than referring to anonymous providers - Dr. Halland Chen, Dr. Rebecca Emch, Dr. Matthew Bennett and Dr. William Lee are listed with their affiliations
- Available in all 50 states, with both molecules and no teaser tier - the rate does not step up as you titrate
- States plainly on its own site that compounded medication is not approved by the FDA and has not been reviewed for safety, effectiveness or quality
- Free expedited shipping on all orders, 24/7 provider messaging, no insurance required and HSA/FSA eligible
The fine print
- Eden's same-price-at-every-dose promise excludes new-member discounts and some plans, so confirm the monthly figure on your checkout screen before you pay
- Eden's custom weight-loss kits are a different product that needs a separate membership ($39 the first month, then $99 a month); the GLP-1 plans do not carry that fee
- FDA issued a warning letter to Eden Health International Inc. dba Eden, dated June 2026. It is public in the FDA warning-letter database and linked from this review so you can read it yourself
- Eden is compounded only - no brand-name Wegovy, Ozempic or Zepbound
- Eden fills prescriptions through its own Eden Pharmacy or unnamed partner pharmacies, so you may not know in advance which one ships your order
NewSelf
NewSelf sells compounded semaglutide with B12 or glycine at $134.99 a month and compounded tirzepatide with B6 and glycine at $224.99, both held flat across every dose, in 49 states.
Why it's a deal
- The rate holds at every dose on both molecules — semaglutide across 0.25 mg to 2.5 mg, tirzepatide across 2.5 mg to 15 mg — so titrating up costs nothing extra
- Both products are compounded with B12, B6 or glycine rather than sold as bare molecules, and the formulation is stated on the product card
- HSA and FSA eligible, with the health screening, shipping and ongoing support inside the price
- Names the 49 states it covers rather than implying nationwide reach
The fine print
- The prominent $99.97 and $144.49 figures are plan floors, not the standing rates — those are $134.99 and $224.99
- Not available in Mississippi or Louisiana
- A "Tirzepatide Plus" tier at $399 a month sits above the standard product, so the flat-rate promise applies within a tier rather than across the range
- Compounded only — no FDA-approved brand-name route
We earn a commission when you start treatment through some links on this site, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a Value Score.
Neither one the right fit? Every program that outscores Eden is ranked on the Eden alternatives ranking, and the same list for the other side is on alternatives to NewSelf.
More head-to-heads
The programs scoring closest to this pair, side by side.
Prices, states and verification reflect each program's public disclosures at last check; the Value Score is our editorial judgment per the methodology. "% vs brand-name self-pay" compares a program's lowest disclosed monthly price against $349/mo, Wegovy's self-pay price at NovoCare Pharmacy, every standard dose after the two-month intro offer (checked October 2026). Prices change — confirm on each provider's site. Not medical advice; see our disclosure.